International cooperation in addressing transnational crime relies heavily on formal mechanisms and frameworks established to ensure law enforcement and judicial processes work across borders. Two such tools are Interpol’s Silver Notices and Mutual Legal Assistance Treaties (MLATs). While both facilitate international collaboration, they serve distinct purposes and operate differently.
What is a Silver Notice?
Silver Notices are a part of Interpol’s color-coded notice system, which helps law enforcement agencies worldwide coordinate efforts related to transnational crimes. Specifically, Silver Notices are issued to track and locate objects of interest, such as vehicles, documents, or equipment connected to a crime.
Key Features of a Silver Notice:
Purpose
Used to request assistance in locating or identifying non-personal objects like stolen items, counterfeit goods, or crime-related equipment.
Scope
It helps disseminate information about these objects quickly and ensures their identification across multiple jurisdictions.
Mechanism
Law enforcement agencies submit a request to Interpol, which circulates the notice to its 195 member countries.
Example Use
Locating a stolen high-value artifact or identifying a vehicle used in international drug trafficking.
A Silver Notice does not pertain to people or involve legal agreements between countries. Instead, it supports tracking criminal activities by focusing on the material evidence associated with crimes.
What are Mutual Legal Assistance Treaties (MLATs)?
MLATs are formal agreements between two or more countries to provide legal assistance in criminal investigations or prosecutions. These treaties establish a structured framework for one country to request help from another in gathering evidence, serving subpoenas, or executing court orders relevant to criminal cases.
Common complaints under MLAT include requests being transferred from one agency to another or one bank to another. Sometimes difficulties arise in obtaining a response because of a large number of requests.
Key Features of MLATs:
Purpose
Facilitate legal cooperation in the prosecution and investigation of crimes, including extradition, sharing evidence, and securing witness testimonies.
Scope
Extends to people, documents, bank records, digital evidence, and any other legal support required for a case.
Mechanism
Requests are made through a central authority, often the justice ministry, and are subject to the terms of the treaty. The legal systems of the involved countries must comply.
Example Use
Securing bank records from another country in a corruption investigation.
MLATs function at a diplomatic level, requiring treaty negotiations, mutual agreements, and adherence to international law, unlike Interpol notices, which are operational tools.
Key Differences Between Silver Notices and MLATs
| Aspect | Silver Notices | Mutual Legal Assistance Treaties (MLATs) |
| Purpose | Locate or identify crime-related objects | Obtain legal evidence or assistance in investigations/prosecutions |
| Scope | Non-personal items such as vehicles, equipment, etc. | People, documents, evidence, and witness cooperation |
| Authority | Issued through Interpol’s network | Based on formal agreements between countries |
| Legal Complexity | Operates within Interpol’s member network | Subject to treaty-specific legal obligations |
| Examples | Identifying stolen artifacts or counterfeit goods | Extraditing suspects or sharing financial records |
What is Interpol mechanism?
The Interpol mechanism refers to the global system and processes by which the International Criminal Police Organization (Interpol) facilitates international cooperation among law enforcement agencies. Interpol connects its 195 member countries to combat transnational crime, ensuring swift sharing of information, resources, and expertise to investigate and combat crimes that cross national borders.
Under the Interpol mechanism, states and central agencies can use the recently introduced Bharatpol to seamlessly send their requests for information through the CBI, which is designated as the National Central Bureau of India for all matters pertaining to the global organisation.
Bharatpol
Bharatpol is a digital platform developed by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) to enhance international police cooperation and streamline criminal investigations involving transnational crimes. Bharatpol serves as a centralized hub for real-time assistance and coordination among Indian law enforcement agencies and their international counterparts.
As the National Central Bureau for INTERPOL in India (NCB-New Delhi), the CBI plays a pivotal role in facilitating international cooperation on criminal cases in collaboration with various law enforcement agencies across the country. This coordination extends across the central, state, and Union Territory levels and is managed through INTERPOL Liaison Officers (ILOs). These ILOs work in conjunction with Unit Officers (UOs), who typically hold positions such as Superintendents of Police, Police Commissioners, or Branch Chiefs within their respective organizations. Currently, communication between the CBI, ILOs, and UOs is primarily conducted through traditional methods, including letters, emails, and faxes.
Key Features of BHARATPOL:
Centralized Platform
BHARATPOL integrates various law enforcement agencies across India, providing a unified interface to manage requests for international assistance through Interpol.
Real-Time Coordination
The portal facilitates swift communication and collaboration in addressing transnational crimes such as cybercrime, human trafficking, financial fraud, and organized crime.
Access to International Support
Field-level officers can utilize BHARATPOL to access international resources and support, enhancing their effectiveness in tackling complex security challenges.
Streamlined Processes
By digitizing and centralizing the process of handling international assistance requests, BHARATPOL reduces delays and improves the efficiency of law enforcement operations.
Conclusion
Both Silver Notices and MLATs are crucial tools for combating transnational crime but differ significantly in focus and application. Silver Notices target the operational need to track or locate objects involved in crimes, while MLATs provide a legal framework to gather evidence or prosecute criminals across borders.
Their effectiveness lies in understanding and leveraging their unique strengths. Coordinating these tools can ensure seamless international cooperation, making the fight against global crime more robust and efficient.
Read More: Customs Dept. Catches 1.94 Kg Gold In Trolley Bag Metal Linings Of A Married Couple
