The role of a GST inspector often leads to confusion regarding their uniform and authority, especially when compared to a regular police inspector. Here’s a detailed breakdown of both aspects:
Uniform of GST Inspectors: Is It Khaki?
Yes, traditionally, Central Excise and Service Tax inspectors wore a khaki uniform, which continued for GST inspectors after the implementation of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in 2017. This is because GST officers were drawn from the erstwhile Central Excise and Customs departments, where khaki uniforms were prescribed under the Central Excise, Circle and Divisional Office Procedure Manual, 1975.
However, there is no specific mention of a khaki uniform in the CGST Act, 2017 or its associated rules. An RTI query filed on July 13, 2017, after GST came into force, asked under which rule Central Excise officers were wearing uniforms post-GST. The CBEC (now CBIC) replied:
“The rule governing the wearing of uniform by Central Excise Officers has not changed after 01.07.2017.”
This means GST inspectors are expected to follow the old uniform norms unless the CBIC issues new guidelines.
However, in practice, many GST inspectors, especially those in non-preventive roles, do not wear uniforms regularly. Moreover, unlike police officers, their uniform does not symbolize law enforcement in the traditional sense.
Powers of GST Inspectors: Are They Like Police Inspectors?
While GST inspectors have significant powers, they do not have the same authority as a police inspector under the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC). Their powers are defined under the CGST Act, 2017, and are limited to tax-related offenses.
Key Powers of a GST Inspector:
- Inspection: Under Section 67 of the CGST Act, a GST inspector can inspect any place of business if they have reason to believe that tax evasion is occurring.
- Search and Seizure: As per Section 67(2), GST officers (of the rank of Inspector and above) can conduct searches and seize goods, documents, or records related to GST violations.
- Arrest: Under Section 69, an officer not below the rank of an Assistant Commissioner can authorize the arrest of a person for specific offenses, such as tax evasion exceeding ₹2 crore.
Key Differences from Police Inspectors:
- GST inspectors cannot file an FIR or investigate criminal cases under the Indian Penal Code (IPC).
- They cannot detain individuals beyond the scope of GST-related inquiries.
- Their powers are restricted to tax administration and do not extend to general law and order.
Uniform and Powers Compared
- Uniform
GST inspectors traditionally wear khaki uniforms, but enforcement varies by region and role. There is no legal mandate in the GST Act for wearing uniforms, and many officers in desk roles do not wear them regularly.
- Powers:
GST inspectors have significant powers under the CGST Act, including search, seizure, and arrest for tax-related offenses. However, they do not have the same authority as police inspectors under the CrPC and cannot investigate general criminal offenses.
In essence, while a GST inspector may wear a khaki uniform and exercise considerable authority within the realm of tax law, they do not function as law enforcement officers like regular police inspectors. Their jurisdiction remains strictly limited to GST-related matters.
Historical Context and Existing Guidelines
Prior to the implementation of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) on July 1, 2017, officers of the Central Excise department were governed by guidelines that prescribed the wearing of uniforms. Specifically, Chapter 7 of the “Central Excise, Circle and Divisional Office Procedure Manual, 1975” outlined the uniform requirements for Central Excise officers. This manual mandated that all Central Excise and Customs officers of and below the rank of Assistant Commissioner, including those in the Preventive Intelligence Branch, must wear uniforms when on duty, both in their offices and while on tour.
With the advent of GST, the Central Board of Excise and Customs (CBEC), now known as the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC), issued a clarification in response to a Right to Information (RTI) query on July 13, 2017. The CBEC stated, “The rule governing the wearing of uniform by Central Excise Officers has not changed after 01.07.2017.”
This indicates that the pre-existing guidelines regarding uniforms remained applicable even after the transition to the GST regime.
Current Applicability to CGST Officers
The CGST Act of 2017 does not contain specific provisions mandating uniforms for its officers. However, Section 3 of the CGST Act stipulates that officers appointed under the Central Excise Act, 1944, are deemed to be officers under the CGST Act. This legal framework suggests that the uniform guidelines outlined in the 1975 manual continue to apply to CGST officers, as they are considered successors to the Central Excise officers.
Practical Implementation and Variations
Despite the existence of these guidelines, the enforcement and adherence to uniform requirements have been inconsistent. Instances have been reported where CGST officers, particularly those in intelligence and preventive roles, do not regularly wear uniforms. This inconsistency has led to confusion and calls for clearer directives from the CBIC. In some cases, officers have been observed drawing uniform allowances without adhering to the uniform-wearing protocol, prompting internal communications and directives to enforce compliance.
Calls for Updated Guidelines
The lack of updated and clear guidelines has led to debates within the department and among stakeholders. Some argue that the traditional khaki uniform may not align with the current functions and public perception of CGST officers, especially when compared to their counterparts in state GST departments who do not wear uniforms. There have been suggestions to either modernize the uniform or abolish it altogether to reflect the evolving nature of tax administration.
Read More: Can GST Appeals Be Filed After Limitation? Supreme Court Clears the Air
